Subscribe to this thread
Home - General / All posts - Mapping Continental Divides
dchall8
1,028 post(s)
#11-May-25 18:53

I found this map in an article I was reading. It seemed like something that could be done in Manifold, more or less like a watershed, but I don't have a feel for the approach and data resources. Has anyone made a map like this that could help out?

Attachments:
Contenental Divides Map.jpg

Dimitri


7,557 post(s)
#12-May-25 06:30

You're right, creating a map like that is working with watersheds, and yes, it could be done in Manifold. Not only that but Manifold would be an especially good tool to create such maps.

The continental divides are the ridges which are the boundaries of the largest scale watersheds in North America. If you have terrain elevation data for North America you can create watershed areas and then convert the watershed areas into the boundary lines of those areas. Do some clean-up and some editing to get the display seen in the map above. Like many such maps it's a simplification.

Topics: Watersheds, Example: Create Watershed Areas, Watershed Areas, Sinks, Upstream Areas and Lines.

If you look at the red lines indicating the Great Divide, rain that falls to the west of the line flows west into the ocean/seas, and rain that falls to the east of the line flows east to the ocean/seas.

The brown line indicating the Great Basin marks a sink, where water that falls into that sink stays in the sink and does not flow to the ocean. I suppose the closed red loop lines in the Great Divide also indicate sinks.

There are many ways of creating a map like this from original data but they all start with creating watersheds from terrain elevation data. Create watersheds that accumulate very large amounts of water to get big watersheds (a map like this doesn't care about small watersheds). From there you can pick out the mouths of major rivers and use Upstream Areas to find all the watersheds that flow into that river. For example, I suppose the Rio Grande and the Mississippi river mouths would pick out many of the watershed areas that abut the Great, Laurentian, St. Lawrence and Eastern Divides around the central part of the US.

I think the essential thing to understand about the map is that somebody interpolated it by eye, not by some universal, perfect algorithm, so I wouldn't spend a lot of effort trying to figure out some way to completely automate it. If you know southern Florida, for example, you know that's not a realistic proposition given the flatness of the Everglades terrain to the south of Lake Okeechobee, where drawing a neat yellow line like shown in the map is more a matter of opinion than perfect physical reality. There's also the reality that wildly varying resolutions of terrain elevation data across a region as big as North America aren't going to result in a single, neat, algorithmic solution.

I think the way the map was drawn was to search the literature on traditional continental and regional divides drawn over the years by geographers who were familiar with each region and to then create a reasonable composite of their maps. It probably wasn't somebody sitting down with high resolution terrain elevation data to compute watersheds.

But if you wanted to create a map from first principles you could do that, and Manifold would certainly be a good choice because it has the horsepower (make sure to have a GPU in your system) to do the watershed computations over lots of terrain elevation data.

Or, if you wanted to do it the more traditional way, take the image you posted and georeference it as a layer. Next, use your favorite AI or a traditional search engine to find online images of maps of continental and regional divides in various regions. Georeference those, stack them up in a map together with the image you posted, and then draw your own lines that reconcile/interpolate to your taste the various proposed divides you found online.

Dimitri


7,557 post(s)
#12-May-25 09:53

Doing an internet search, the map you posted is a Wikimedia Commons image that was created by eye from other maps online that purport to show divides. There are many, many sources for such images of maps, and even GIS data, like the US Fish and Wildlife shapefile for the continental divide in on the https://gis-fws.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/fws::continental-divide-pacific-atlantic/about page. So that's a quick way to make your own by doing what that contributor did.

Doing online searches for shapefiles of continental divides, I found the original CEC data set from which that map apparently was made. It's no longer at the original CEC link, but the waybackmachine found it: https://web.archive.org/web/20130114144353/http://www.cec.org/Page.asp?PageID=924&ContentID=2866 what's interesting is that the links on the waybackmachine archived page to download the shapefile are still live and pointing to downloadable data. The metadata .doc file on that archived page is also still live.

Download the metadata .doc and it tells you the data set is called "North American Atlas – Basin Watersheds". Search for that online and you find the ever-helpful ArcGIS.com page that has the data with a Files Download link to the current CEC data set, at https://www.cec.org/north-american-environmental-atlas/watersheds/

I downloaded the shapefile and styled it by unique values in the NAW2_EN field. I then overlaid a continental divide shapefile from USGS that shows the Great Divide, styling it as a red line with white borders to set it off from the clutter below. The image below shows that.

It's a trivial operation in Manifold to select all of the watershed areas to the west of that red line and to make them a single area. You can then take the boundary of that area and cut out all but the part that corresponds to the red line. Do that with the other watershed area groupings using the original image from Wikipedia as a guide.

Note that the "official" USGS and Canadian national atlases do not agree with what the anonymous contributor to Wikimedia Commons drew, even though his or her map is the one that is widely reproduced as being "authoritative." For example, the Wikipedia map shows the St. Lawrence divide extending into the island of Nova Scotia, which is a mistake. It should follow the USGS/Canadian watersheds close along the St. Lawrence river waterway, at the end heading towards Anticosti Island. It also shows the wrong watershed boundary for Newfoundland. It also disagrees with the USGS/Canadian atlas in southern Florida, as well as in other places.

Attachments:
basins01.png

Mike Pelletier


2,151 post(s)
#12-May-25 14:04

Nice to see a more accurate version. Interesting how small the watershed for the Great Lakes is in comparison to the rest of the continent.

Manifold User Community Use Agreement Copyright (C) 2007-2021 Manifold Software Limited. All rights reserved.